I am much less negative on Tim Cook and I’ll tell you why:
Steve Jobs was a great vision leader but something of a bad manager in other ways. Being an asshole doesn’t magically make his track record perfect, especially if we include his first stint at Apple.
He was a great leader of a growth company. He motivated and sourced talent very well in his own strange way.
Tim Cook is extremely good at the logistics of a large and mature company, and Apple doesn’t need a Steve Jobs because it doesn’t need to grow.
Apple doesn’t need to do any of the shit that you’ve criticized them for doing badly. It doesn’t need the Vision Pro or an AI product at all. It doesn’t even need to innovate anymore, ever.
Apple is now entrenched in a duopoly. It literally can’t fail. They are basically like AT&T now.
They’ll make more money reselling cloud storage and bundling a glorified cable subscription with it. They probably make more money on their stupid credit card than OpenAI will ever make.
Hell, their services division makes more revenue than Macs and iPads combined IIRC.
Perhaps Tim Cook’s only failure is not canceling the Vision Pro product and not delaying Apple Intelligence. But the consequences of those actions are minimal if any. They probably sold the iPhone 16 Pro to millions of morons who don’t even care about the AI rug pull.
With a company so large, Tim Cook’s most important job is keeping the machine running, staying on the good side of all the countries involved politically, things of that nature. And in that sense he’s done a great job.