The only way this doesn't work is if the aliens who retrieve the plaque from deep space somehow stabilize in the long term at a point where they've developed rocketry and general space travel but not radio or an understanding of quantum mechanics.
However the above would seem to imply that they don't do radio astronomy, don't have a very good understanding of light (since it's all photons), and don't have high frequency electronic circuits (since designing those requires accounting for RF interference). I guess their understanding of optics is also lacking and their understanding of chemistry is rudimentary and stagnant over the long term.
In other words, aliens permanently stuck at a late 1800s technology level that have nonetheless developed the ability to travel across interstellar distances. And spotted voyager (a very small cold object in deep space). And retrieved it intact.
That's undoubtedly a very cool premise for a scifi story but as far as real life goes I think your time would be better spent worrying that voyager might be eaten by a species of space fairing wale.