The rest of your comment boils down to "skills issue". I mean, OK. But you can say that about any programming environment, including writing in raw assembly.
The rest of your comment boils down to "skills issue". I mean, OK. But you can say that about any programming environment, including writing in raw assembly.
It's like imagine saying, I don't want to learn how write a good story because AI always suggests me writing a bad one anyway. May be that delivers the idea better.
Why would I valorize discarding this kind of automation? Is this just a craft vs. production thing? Like, the same reason I'd use only hand tools when doing joinery in Japanese-style woodworking? There's a place for that! But most woodworkers... use table saws and routers.
That implies that proponents of such approach don't want to pursue learning which requires them to do something that exceeds the mediocrity level set by the AI they rely on.
For me it's obvious that it has a major negative impact on many things.
Basically, learn Rust based on whether it's helping solve your issues better, not on whether some LLM is useless or not useless in this case.
The strongest reason I can think of to discard this kind of automation, and do so proudly, is that it's effectively plagiarizing from all of the experts whose code was used in the training data set without their permission.
Artists can come at me with this concern all they want, and I feel bad for them. No software developer can.
I disagree with you about the "plagiaristic" aspect of LLM code generation. But I also don't think our field has a moral leg to stand on here, even if I didn't disagree with you.
As for our tendency to disrespect the copyrights of art, clearly we've always been in the wrong about this, and we should respect the rights of artists. The fact that we've been in the wrong about this doesn't mean we should redouble the offense by also plagiarizing from other programmers.
And there is evidence that LLMs do plagiarize when generating code. I'll just list the most relevant citations from Baldur Bjarnason's book _The Intelligence Illusion_ (https://illusion.baldurbjarnason.com/), without quoting from that copyrighted work.
https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.07646
https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3447548.3467198
https://papers.nips.cc/paper/2020/hash/1e14bfe2714193e7af5ab...
I stand by that argument, but acknowledge it isn't relevant here.
My bigger thing is just, having the experience of writing many thousands of lines of backend code with an LLM (just yesterday), none of what I'm looking at can meaningfully be described as "plagiarized". It's specific to my problem domain (indeed, to my extremely custom stack) and what isn't domain-specific is just extremely generic stuff (opening a boltdb, printing a table with lipgloss), just assembled precisely.