Furthermore, investors tend to demand extra terms on top. The big one here is called liquidation preference, which is a clause that says, approximately, if/when this company is sold, this investor gets the first X amount of it, usually corresponding to some multiplier of their investment amount. Later rounds will ask to win out in preference, effectively creating a stack of liquidation preferences. In practice, liquidation preferences can often add up to so much that a moderately-successful sale goes entirely to preferred shareholders, and common shareholders see nothing. Perhaps the dealmakers put in a bit of a sweetener for the founders and/or current executives to grease the deal. Your average employee and angel or seed investors certainly see nothing in this deal.
The stake should remain the same, but double in value. That's the risk of early investment being paid out.
I'm really surprised it doesn't work that way.
The other thing to keep in mind is that institutional investors will generally insist that founders earn out their stake via vesting over, say, 4 years. Then, the founders' stake, despite being earmarked for them, aren't officially theirs yet.
For example, lets say a company is valued at 100mil with 50mil in preferred stock and 50mil in common stock where the preferred stock is owned by institutional investors and everyone else (including founders and angel investors) has common stock. Lets say there are two founders that own 10% each, an angel which owns 10%, and an employee options pool with the remaining 20%.
Now lets say there are two scenarios:
1. The company is sold for 90mil, 50m goes to preferred stock, and the remaining 40m goes to the common pool — 8m to each founder and angel and 16m to the options pool.
2. The company is sold for 50m, but the founders each get a salary of 5m for 3 years. The preferred stock gets the entire 50m. The angel and employee pools get 0, and the founders get 15m each.
In scenario 2 the preferred stock gets their share, the founders come out ahead by 7m each, AND the buyer has to pay 10m less than option 1. But the angel and employees get shafted.
This has happened plenty of times where a startup in a dire situation had to sell itself or raise a down round with poor terms to survive and the earlier investors got wiped out.