By the way, I don’t think anyone wants to return fully to those times. The question is, on what ways can we return and get the maximum benefit for our people? That is a conversation worth having.
You need to make some of that quantitative to even have a reasonable discussion about it or we are just talking about mental images, whether that be little house on the prairie or the artful dodger.
Your chronological snobbery reminds me of a similar blindness that modernity has for the "women and children first" policy when the Titanic was sinking. When they made the movie, the director deliberately altered the story because he believed nobody would believe the truth. Yet the truth is, women and children were a whole lot more likely to survive than men, indicating that policy must have taken place[1].
The reality is, if you read first-hand accounts of the west, you see an incredible optimism, an incredible amount of sacrifice and an incredible amount of shared community on the west. That is so alien to our modern culture, where most people know a prophet of doom and gloom, people think that "community" is something you can purchase with a membership or find online, and conspiracy theories (real and imagined!) are a constant hot topic.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_and_children_first#20th_...
It’s interesting that you’re accusing me of snobbery when I’ve made no quality arguments at all. Yet you have very specific descriptions of now that villainize it in as broad strokes as you praised the past.