And did we ever need this tool? Prettier and eslint are different beasts, both pretty good, and integrate well together. But again, it's not the tools themselves that are interesting, it's the way Rome was talked about so much without existing. When prettier appeared it was just released: "here is a new tool to format things, it's much faster than what we had before." It then took a long time to permeate and become essential, and it improved along the way, became multi language etc. Prettier is a thing, a tool, it has no mission other than what it does. Rome was an idea without a tool, and it never came to fruition.
You could make some kind of conclusion about this, that oss projects based on grand ideas are doomed, you need code to be released first, to build on and grow. But I don't think that conclusion in itself is that interesting, certainly not novel. What's interesting is why did Rome happen, why did the people behind it drive it in that way? Why did so many get excited by it? It's so very similar to companies that hype themselves stratospherically and often fail. Except at least there is a point to their hype: get investment money and try and use that money to make the hype reality. I don't understand the purpose behind the same thing with Rome. It really itches at me to know more, to understand. To understand why it appealed so much to my peers, it's just linting and formatting, we have that already, and any new tool will start with rough edges. Sometimes you see similar a sort thing with projects and think it's based on aggrandizement of the dev behind it, but those projects peter out quickly. Rome kept it going for years.