Hacker News Reader

The reason I wrote my own tool is because I couldn't find anything for Pg17 at the time and pgbackrest seemed overkill for my needs. Also, the CLI handles backup rotations as well. Barman looks interesting though, I'll definitely have a look, thanks!

View on HN

pgbackrest was always easy to use in my experience. Not very hard to setup or configure, and low overhead. Supports spool directories for WAL shipping, compression, and block incremental backups (YAY!!!). I ran my last company on it for the last ~6 years I was there. Never any complaints, solid software (which is what you want for backups).

I have been using barman indirectly through CloundNativePG with my latest company, but don't have the operational experience to speak on it yet.

pgbackrest only looks scary because it’s so flexible, but the defaults work great in almost all cases. The most complex thing you’ll need to do is creating a storage bucket to write to, and configure the appropriate storage provider in pgbackrest's config file.

When it’s set up properly, it’s solid as rock. I’d really recommend you check it out again; it likely solves everything you did more elegantly, and also covers a ton of things you didn’t think of. Been there, done that :)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com