So much about investing, VC's claim, is investing "in the team", and trying to figure out "what kind of people" the founders are.
After all, you're not being hired for a well-defined position -- your success may depend on your very character as a human being. Your drive, your persistence, and your ability to inspire others.
But since these things can't ever be objectively measured, there's tons of opportunity for stereotypes (conscious and unconscious) to affect the process.
There's a positive side to going with your "gut instinct", and a negative side as well.