This is why we should have laws that say that even a small software update requires testing by an independent organization for at least several months.
This is why we should have laws that say that even a small software update requires testing by an independent organization for at least several months.
If this had been the policy, we’d still be technologically in the 18th century.
Would you rather be the world’s richest person in 1825 or lower middle class today?
I like antibiotics, MRI, anesthetics during surgeries, unlimited information and entertainment, and the ability to travel places in less than 8 weeks and without getting tuberculosis along the way.
Tech advancement has given the most people the most happiness, safety and prosperity.
And it’s still barely a drop in the bucket compared to what is plainly visible already as the next level up.
With better testing procedures, would we have gotten here sooner, in the same amount of time, or slower?
My contention is slower. And this seems obvious, because in any Cold War sabotage handbook for slowing down a project, the first rule is to insist on more documentation, more consensus, more verification and validation: i.e. more "testing" and less "push to prod".
You are also sort of begging the question. Better testing wouldn't be better if it was worse.
If one of the things I mentioned doesn't cause our extinction, it's only a matter of time until one of our inventions does, if we don't consider the effects broadly enough before putting it in production at a large scale.
Anyway giving a choice of bleeding tech or being slightly more conservative tech is something that is taken away by people like Musk. Maybe you prefer being such a choice-less 'slave' to the system and uber rich just to have some shiny new toy a bit earlier, most people don't and many systems consider it outright illegal.
I don't get how tesla is not already sued in Europe for massive frauds they did and do on their customers. I'll happily buy electric car in future but hell will freeze sooner than my family sponsoring those nazi cars, competition is pretty good these days.
It wasn’t while we were figuring it out. And we still have active greenfield development in military and experimental aircraft. It would make sense to freeze development once we figure out what works. But in the meantime we need an open field for the technology to develop, lest we become another Europe to China.
Health and safety, and public safety, are as much an innovation as anything else since then.
The laws that say we need testing etc. come from the observable dangers of much of the tech of the 18th and 19th and 20th century. The rules that say we can't buy thorium toothpaste any more* and why car headlights and signal lights are mandatory, are written in blood — and you can witness the result of failing to adhere to such principles and winging it with stuff like the 2020 Beirut explosion, or even that the first Starship test flight covered a nearby city in dust from the destruction of the insufficient concrete launch pad.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doramad_Radioactive_Toothpaste
We humans don’t do moderation well. The two alternatives seem to be move fast and break things vs don’t move at all. Run or sit still. Free for all or stilted hyperconservative society.
If you can figure out a way to make congress to do anything but waste space and time, let us all know. Maybe states (e.g. California, not the normal sense of the term) can regulate some sanity into Tesla.
https://www.wired.com/story/crowdstrike-outage-update-window...
> CrowdStrike wrote in a blog post that the root cause of the crash had been a single configuration file pushed as an update to Falcon.
"Small software update" - good luck qualifying what this is
"independent organization" - ever been audited? auditors love repeat business...
I said "__even__ a small software update", so in fact, every software update, no matter how small.