Hacker News Reader

Comment by mbreese | Hacker News Reader

Can't you use RDS like any MySQL database? And since you're writing a standard WSGI app, it seems like there is very little lock-in. This seems to basically automate the provisioning of EC2 instances for the web app and the DB. and since you just have a standard app, you're free to move it around as needed.

Or is there something that I'm missing with the Elastic Beanstalk? (I've only used raw EC2)

View on HN

Yes RDS is like any MySQL db. The key word there being MySQL. If you want to use another data store like say, postgres or even some NoSQL solution. You're outta luck.

As for platform lock-in, my comments were less towards the web services level and more about system level concerns. It's not entirely clear how you would run persistent background tasks (read: celery). This doesn't even get into the headaches of learning yet another DSL to define OS packaging requirements.

That being said, IMO this would be great for simple apps, with no strenuous requirements. In addition, anything that allows more people to easily deploy their django apps is a good thing.

RDS isn't just MySQL - you can also use Oracle or SQL Server, if you don't want MySQL.

For NoSQL, look at the other stuff that doesn't have 'Relational' in the name :) (DynamoDB, SimpleDB, etc.)

Yes, RDS works with MySQL. And you're right about the provisioning for the EC2 instances for beanstalk, but it doesn't do much for RDS, that needs to be set up independently.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com