Why do they have to be dialectical in the first place? What is your reason for trying to categorize either career? Do you have any supporting evidence for your claims?

We can't meaningfully discuss these questions without more context. Your title is a loaded question; most people don't try to label each archetype because they can be radically different people. By presupposing that they exist in different worlds, you're already making this question hostile to interpretation and response. Please, if you have to beg the question like this, at least illustrate your thought process so we can understand what you're trying to say.