Hacker News Reader

Comment by II2II | Hacker News Reader

That would be akin to describing a computer as a complicated arrangement of switches that control each other through pulses of electricity to do useful stuff. While it may satisfy a bunch of people who aren't really interested in how computers work, and it may even inspire a few people who are intrigued by how such a simple notion could produce incredible results, it doesn't really explain how computers work.

View on HN

Splashy complicated water is an accurate but imprecise description, which is exactly what you want for an introduction. It's a complex chaotic system.

Computers are a terrible analogy for this type of minimal explanation of natural phenomena because computers are layers of designed complexity built by exploiting an understanding of multiple distinct natural phenomena... At the composite scale computers are a very unatural human construct, not something emergent that can be accurately expressed informally.

But it is actually a bit more accurate than saying, electricity goes in and information comes out

Information and electricity go in and information and heat go out, to be pedantic about a simplification.

Electricity and possibly information, unless you're considering the structure itself to be information. Some ASICs only need to be powered on, for example.

If you're going to be pedantic, information and heat go into and come out of just about everything

Reply on news.ycombinator.com