> Or do you think the market is inefficient enough for a person smart enough to be able to outperform it by thinking?
The market cannot be “efficient” (though this isn't what “efficient” means in economics besides in EMH), because if it was efficient, then there would be no incentives for market makers, and as such there wouldn't be anyone working to make it efficient.
As such, the market is always in an in-between state, inefficient enough so that people spend energy to try beat the average, but still hard to beat because there are already many players out there.