Again, I'm not claiming there is a "right" p/e ratio. High is relative though, and relative to historic ratios the market is overvalued roughly on the scale of the leadup to the dotcom bubble. Are you arguing that isn't the case, or that just doesn't matter and isn't a good indicator?
> they would have missed almost all of the nice long rally that came in the decades after.
I wasn't saying to buy and sell as the ratio goes above/below some specific threshold. More importantly though, this is ultimately cherry picking. You can always look back at historic data and define a start point, or a start and end point, to make an argument work. That has little, if any, weight on predicting what will happen in the future.
I'm being pretty careful here to not claim to know what prices or the economy will look like in the future. I'm simply sharing my read on p/e ratios, what my own take away from they is, and where what I see as historic outliers are.