IRS should send me an itemized bill using every piece of information it already has, I then take that to my accountant that generates a diff based on information they don't have, and then done.
You pay the bill they send you, you are done.
You pay the bill they send you, you are done.
I have a reasonably simple personal economy and it takes me all of five minutes to file my taxes in Sweden. My parents have a much more complicated setup (small private business, own a couple of properties, several deductions, etc.) and it basically is pretty straight-forward for them as well, certainly they don't need an accountant.
TurboTax, Intuit and anti-tax Republicans has really fucked with the US expectation of how complicated taxes needs to be.
Yes, keep telling yourself they don't (for what it matters)
In fact if you get a W2 the IRS already have it
Just think what someone with a gazillion dollars, some trusts, and "charitable foundations" could do.
But if by law something needs to be known by the government: just go for it
A silly analogy: your medical info is private, but it's in your best interest that a condition like 'diabetic' or 'allergic to something' have a lower level of privacy
> But if by law something needs to be known by the government: just go for it
This seems a bit flipped, the only reason something needs to be provided to the government “by law” is that we’ve passed a law that says it needs to be. That it is required by law is not a reason for it being required of course, that’s circular. The reason the law was passed is because we decided it was in the public interest for the government to collect that data.
If we decided it was in the public interest to collect more income info about wealthy people, then we could make that required by law. I think the comment you responded to is suggesting that we should change what is required by law.
Your analogy is better. There’s a reason you might be ok with less privacy there.