The problem is that they're all clamoring for more than their fair share of my attention, even when what they have to offer doesn't make a lot of sense. Profitable recruiters are optimizing for the first candidate who didn't resign and wasn't bad enough to dismiss in the first n months, because they aren't rewarded any more for better diligence and outstanding candidate/position fits (if anything, mediocre fits and turnover yield more business down the line).