Current 5 year CD APYs are 4.2-4.7%, while current new car auto loan APRs are 5.2-6.7%.
There is usually no magic spread to be captured unless you’re willing to take more risk (say, money in equities instead of CDs). Financing a depreciating asset against one that is volatile in the short term (and has seen drawdowns of 20% several times in the last 10 years) is a duration to risk mismatch.
That spread capture argument often is just justification for a bad decision - people don’t in practice use credit as liquidity backed by an investment, they use it as a cash advance to buy more car than they would absent financing.
So now instead of buying a $20k car cash, people will buy a $40k car, increasing their debt load against a depreciating asset.
In general, my theory is… if that small spread from borrowing to buy a depreciating asset makes a significant difference to you financially, you can’t afford that car anyway, and you’re better off buying cheaper.
Sorry to unload a bit… that wasn’t about you, that was about me being triggered by seeing this advice a lot :)