> To directly measure the real-world impact of AI tools on software development, we recruited 16 experienced developers from large open-source repositories (averaging 22k+ stars and 1M+ lines of code) that they’ve contributed to for multiple years. Developers provide lists of real issues (246 total) that would be valuable to the repository—bug fixes, features, and refactors that would normally be part of their regular work. Then, we randomly assign each issue to either allow or disallow use of AI while working on the issue. When AI is allowed, developers can use any tools they choose (primarily Cursor Pro with Claude 3.5/3.7 Sonnet—frontier models at the time of the study); when disallowed, they work without generative AI assistance. Developers complete these tasks (which average two hours each) while recording their screens, then self-report the total implementation time they needed. We pay developers $150/hr as compensation for their participation in the study.
So it's a small sample size of 16 developers. And it sounds like different tasks were (randomly) assigned to the no-AI and with-AI groups - so the control group doesn't have the same tasks as the experimental group. I think this could lead to some pretty noisy data.
Interestingly - small sample size isn't in the list of objections that the auther includes under "Addressing Every Objection You Thought Of, And Some You Didn’t".
I do think it's an interesting study. But would want to see if the results could be reproduced before reading into it too much.