Is Google App Engine successful?
news.cnet.com
news.cnet.com
But we host our http://www.versionsapp.com site on it and that works extremely well: http://www.madebysofa.com/#blog/appengine_hosting
Although I suppose you could say this means it also suffers from anti-evangelism, because after using it for a project I warned everyone else that was interested, "It's not ready, don't bother."
If Google was doing a better job highlighting companies or projects using the service, posting interesting articles, actually improving the service based on feedback -- they might have gained more traction by now.
They are wholly inconsistent, the last blog post was a month ago.
You can't just launch a service and wait for ... magic. You'd think that Goog would understand this.
App Engine isn't dead by far, but it could be a much bigger player in the cloud space if someone at Google would wake up.
I'm actually quite impressed with their work. The platform (despite its limitations) is extremely easy to work on and they seem to be implementing features & fixing bugs at a good pace.
They also hold a bi-monthly IRC chat with developers.
I think the primary advantage is being able to harness Google's architecture for zippy data retrieval, but they then handicap it by putting limits on how much data you can dump. They probably will offer a tiered pricing structure to allow massive dataset uploads.
But that's a problem in a way: your competition is about to increase several orders of magnitude as server cost goes to zero. Think of all those high school and university students who will be attempting their own web startups.
you are all aware with the limitations (eg comet support and cron jobs being the biggest), but it is still not bad for quick prototyping and even releasing sites with medium levels of complexity (ive written a simple chess site - wizchess.appspot.com - does the basic game play and all but lots lots lots of polish required)...
but it certainly goes with google's philosopy of "fail often, fail early" (or the other way around).. essentially they are developing the api in tangent with developers who require new features though it has been slow late i think...