But if it helps you avoid cognitive dissonance to conclude that he has no clue, that's your choice.
Proving what exactly? Billy Graham is (was) also a well-regarded public speaker. This claim doesn't support the depth of his ideas, and can't compare to examining the ideas themselves.
His ratings in an community unknown to me don't impress me at all. I mean it is cool, but I still look at what he says with skepticism. The world is full of famous people who are wrong.
I think that this is appropriate. If you've thought about sexism, and have observed skeptic communities, then you'll have no trouble recognizing the validity of his observations based on your own. If you have not observed skeptic communities, then you can either take his word for it, or else go out and do your own first hand observations. And finally if you've never actually thought much about sexism, well, how could he reasonably begin to explain?
In short, either you get it and further explanation is superfluous, or else you don't and his attempting to enlighten you would take him seriously off course. Either way there is no point in having him try to present an airtight logical argument.
Can we say that HN is a skeptic community, for example? Would you say HN is very sexist? Or do only "skeptic communities" that are actually sexist count?
I don't believe I see intelligent people, like you, use someone's programming credentials as support for an ideologically motivated axe job in a non-programming subject. :-(
There is an old Swedish saw, badly translated as "where liquor go in, sense go out". Just do s/liquor/ideology/
Stephen Bond, who wrote the linked page, is at http://plover.net/~bonds/. I could not find any OSCON talks by him. Can you please provide a link? I think you are confusing them based on the similar domain names.
Yes, because "no true sceptic" would be sexist and/or a Star Trek fan right?
Have you been to ACTUAL sceptic forums and web circles? He might miss a few outliers, but his actual criticisms are spot on in the main.
I didn't speak about some sceptics, much less about ONE. I spoke about what qualities I saw in the majority of them. Hence, I fail to see how your sarcastic comment applies here.
As I said in another comment: if he can not even avoid basic logical fallacies, he probably never was a very good skeptic to begin with.
Of course not.
But as he, I also noticed a lot of them being sexist.
At some point you have to stop the "just because X is A and B, doesn't mean that every A is B", and make an empirical observation based on the statistical information you have available.
Else you fall into the "no true scotchman" fallacy.
And which skeptics community are you referring to? Climate skeptics? Sexism skeptics? Religion skeptics? I am not even sure what skeptics communities there are, and certainly they don't all agree with each other. I am sure there are climate change skeptic skeptics for example.
No, but I do claim that the "all" quantifier is useless in human affairs. Why even try to rephrase my statement with "all"? To make it more like a strawman?
What I claim is: "there are many sexist skeptics, period". I don't care if not "all" of them are. I know that I met a large percentage that were, and that it is enough for me to not like those kind of communities.
Plus, it's not that I just dislike their sexism, I dislike their general attitude, which the original article describes quite accurately. That is, they made "thinking independently" into a religious-like dogma.
>I am not even sure what skeptics communities there are, and certainly they don't all agree with each other.
I mean the general "Carl Sagan, Dawkins, James Randi, etc are gods among men, let's hang around internet forums and sites and debunk junk science, lament for the lack of scientific knowledge, waste time arguing with conspiracy theorists, religious nuts, et al" kind of sceptic communities. Maybe with some Ayn Rand thrown in for good measure.