Hacker News Reader

Comment by reliabilityguy | Hacker News Reader

> An operation by a state to purge itself of an ethnic group?

Palestinians do not live in Israel. So, Israel is not purging “itself”. If you claim that Israel wants to remove all the Arabs, then why it does not wage war on its own Arab citizens?

> But a civil war implies both sides having a similar ability level.

What? It makes no sense. In Lebanese civil war you had at least 4 sides, and they were vastly different in their abilities. Civil war implies that everyone involved is a citizen, which is not the case here.

> And a war in the year 2025 normally implies mainly hitting military targets - the enemy's civilians are to be subjugated, not killed.

In any war civilians die, especially if the war involves guerrillas. Look at Myanmar: civil war, guerrilla groups, a lot of dead civilians.

View on HN

Israel is purging the land it wants to take, which is contained within the "borders" of what Israel considers its own land, whose citizens are restricted by the Israeli military, socially and economically.

Yeah, civilians die. But Israel targets civilians, not combatants.

> Israel is purging the land it wants to take, which is contained within the "borders" of what Israel considers its own land

Israel left Gaza in 2005. Why leave the land “ which is contained within the "borders" of what Israel considers its own land”?

> Yeah, civilians die. But Israel targets civilians, not combatants.

You would have to prove that. So far, if targeting civilians was the goal, then Israel why send ground forces into Gaza in the first place? It makes no sense.

Israel says that Palestine doesn't exist and that land is part of Israel.

> Israel says that Palestine doesn't exist and that land is part of Israel.

Israel is not a person, and cannot “say” things. At least 20% of Israelis are Arabs, I doubt that they also “saying” that.

Politicians come and go, opinions change.

Regardless, if you like to participate in a proper discourse, I’m all ears. However, so far it seems that your arguments are more emotional rather than factual.

David Ben Avraham is a converted Jewish Israeli who grew up in Palestine. He was stopped arbitrarily by an IDF soldier, who asked his name, and then immediately shot him dead.

I bring this up because I'm tired of hearing "some Israelis are Arabs" as if to blame the Arabs for not becoming Israelis. There's a reason they don't.

I am confused here. What are you trying to say?

Wankers like you often are.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com