Hacker News Reader

Seems like the heap allocator has a bug if it doesn't handle invalidating the free hint before it returns it to the application. This does raise the question of why MADV_FREE works on the basis of writes rather than accesses -- there are PTE bits for both cases right, and it would have been just as easy to have any access cancel the free hint? (I am assuming x86 here.)

View on HN

That could be classified as a bug if it was decided that the allocator must guarantee that uninitialized memory is readable as a consistent value. Otherwise, making the allocator clear the hint is just unnecessary work.

Clearing the hint on read would probably be more sane, but would mean many more potential situations of unnecessarily losing it (GC doing unnecessary scanning, doing a heap dump, debuggers trying to read it, other sorts of memory scanning)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com