Single username isn't privileged data. But a set of usernames and realnames can be. It's better to lose a pendrive with encrypted block256.dat than Passwords\HackerNews\dfcsd.gpg, Passwords\Bank\34457356.gpg, Passwords\Mail\name.gmail.gpg etc.
There's the difference, I think; I shred all my personally identifiable trash (well, recycling, actually).