Portability between Passkey managers is still an issue though. Last I checked there were in draft specs for migrating between managers but nothing ready yet.
Portability between Passkey managers is still an issue though. Last I checked there were in draft specs for migrating between managers but nothing ready yet.
Of course they'll happily justify it with security reasons, but that doesn't remove the problem.
Considering there isn't really anything you can do with the private key other than logging in to a website, making phishing impossible is a higher priority than letting people view the keys. There are alternative open source passkey managers which do let you view them. But it seems pretty obvious the average person is much better off not having this.
And what you can do or want to do with your private key is really up to you. Copy it and import into another password manager could be a reasonable use case, besides simple curiosity. Basically, slapping on it some kind of DRM-like restrictions in the name of security isn't right.
You can make it non trivial to make it more clear that it has risks, but not prevent users from accessing it if they insist.
You can also use KeepassX which lets you export the keys in plain text which would be the power user option. Passkeys as a tech doesn't stop you doing this, only the mainstream Passkey managers.
> I've already heard rumblings that KeepassXC is likely to be featured in a few industry presentations that highlight security challenges with passkey providers, the need for functional and security certification, and the lack of identifying passkey provider attestation (which would allow RPs to block you, and something that I have previously rallied against but rethinking as of late because of these situations).
Or in less patronizing terms: "do what we want or we're blacklisting you."
It's not reasonable to remove all agency from users because they sometimes click through warnings. Scammers will do the exact same refund scam script that they do today, and at no point will a passkey stop someone from doing a sketchy money transfer, or letting the scammer control their computer.
It just doesn't make sense to impose these extreme restrictions on exporting passkeys that won't stop the most common phone scams sctipts at all.