Hacker News Reader

I wrote a blog post some time ago which contrasts the "Schwartzian transform" with the slightly clearer alternative used by most APL-family languages and (in my opinion) an even cleaner approach which is possible in languages with a first-class table type: https://beyondloom.com/blog/rankingoffruits.html

View on HN

That was a lovely vignette, thanks. Much earlier in my career I had exactly the sense suggested that “something’s off” about the Schwartzian, even though it became a useful and idiomatic tool at the time. I only really understood the disquiet much later, when working with columnar data, and realising the positive qualities of declaring structs-of-arrays rather than arrays-of-structs, with subsequently excellent mechanical sympathy, and so on from there.

Unfortunately, the only such language to which most workaday devs have access is some dialect of SQL. Fortunately, at least there's that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com