I know parents who start their children racing motocross dirtbikes around age 6. (Meanwhile, my brother is making sure his dinner table corners are padded for his 7 year old to not run into... different parenting styles, I guess)
I agree that we shouldn't let fear rule us, but I think the risk of fatal and disfiguring accidents is high on roadways in the US. It's kind of like letting your cat be an outdoor cat, but instead of a sad nextdoor post we are going to be seeing teen funerals