Hacker News Reader

Maybe they asked GPT-5 to update slides.

GPT-5 would've caught this mismatch for sure

That seemingly depends a bit on how hard you ask it to think, or how hard it decides to think based on your question.

"ChatGPT, this slide deck feels a bit luke warm, help me make a better impression"

I could completely believe someone who is all-in on the tech, working in marketing, and not really that familiar with the failure modes, using a prompt like this and just missing the bad edit.

Claude and ChatGPT actually took me several prompts to get them to identify this. They recognized from a screenshot that labeled axes that start at zero can be misleading, but missed the actual issue.

thats hilarious actually. gives credence to the gpt theory haha

How hard would it be for the model to be like: "Okay, there's a bar chart in the picture, the left bar is 350 px in size and the right bar is 120 px. Meanwhile, the labeled values are X and Y, which doesn't seem to match those relative sizes due to this math I ran thanks to all the cool deterministic tools I have."

Apparently quite a bit.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com