You're not allowed to say that it's not reasoning without distinguishing what is reasoning. Absent a strict definition that the models fail and that some other reasoner passes, it is entirely philosophical.
If it’s truly reasoning, then it wouldn’t be able to deceive or to rationalize a leaked answer in a backwards fashion. Asking and answering those questions can help us understand how the research agendas for improving reasoning and improving alignment should be modified.
I don't think this means what you think it means... Philosophers (at least up to Wittgenstein) love constructing and arguing about definitions.