It can never make it impossible.
> These are full of bugs, so that will work for a while, until it doesn’t.
You're forgetting that vendors have to implement this into a pretty complicated system already and that configuration space is constantly changing due to new CPUs and other hardware coming into existence. There will always be holes due to emergent configuration and implementation issues.
> but HVCI will make this a pain once ubiquitously required.
Then there will be new pressure to get at the underlying keys that protect the system. When you consider the size of the keys vs. the size of the reward for liberating them it's obvious how this is going to play out.
> And you have to do all of this while also not being detected for aberrant behavior
For tournaments I don't understand the problem. Every other modern non computer based sport has this issue. They understand they can't be perfect, and any attempts to do so would ruin the nature of the competition itself, so you're better off recording as much data, video and audio from the player as you possibly can. That way if there are any accusations later you have the data to consider them.
This is a race to a corporate controlled future for no particularly good reason.