Artist/Album/Track# - Song name [- Artist name]
The last is only there for soundtracks and other "Various Artists" type collections.
This is Good Enough [tm] for me. I can sync this across hard drives (backup), minimize duplicates (although I end up with these through compilations of various sorts), etc.
Unfortunately the ID3 tag system is All Wrong [tm] for this in many ways stated (in this post and elsewhere). For example:
- Albums don't really have an artist; songs do;
- Programs for automating this that get info from Amazon and elsewhere tend to use what year the particular CD was released rather than when it was originally released, which is far more useful and relevant (eg if you want the Beatles White album you don't care the CD was released in 1998, it should come up under 1968;
- Albums don't really have years either. Or at least they have publication years. The songs have years. Normal studio albums have a common year. Compilations and soundtracks do not;
- Genres are coarse-grained, arbitrary and (IMHO) mostly useless;
- What I like is greatly influenced by the circumstances around the song, sometimes more than the song itself. I might like a song because it reminds me of a particular person, place or event. Or even mood. Sometimes its the lyrics. Sometimes its the sound. No recommendation engine is going to capture this sort of angle.
This goes beyond music: people just aren't interested in classifying, well, pretty much anything. Playlists seem to be about as far as most people are willing to go. Playlists are a fairly convenient way of coming up with s event-specific music eg for working out, for relaxing, for dancing, for a party, etc.
Efforts at far strong and more accurate metadata, classification and organization speak more about one's festidious--even anal-retentiveness--more than any real need or better outcome (IMHO). It's just rabbit-holing really.