First: Yes, I agree.
Second: Hmm... I don't know. People talk about ghosts a lot as well. There are many people who claim that they see ghosts. But I don't think that is strong evidence that ghosts exist.
Third: We need a consistent definition of consciousness here. It would waste a lot of time if it turned out we were debating different concepts. I believe your idea of consciousness is that it is an emergent phenomenon that arises from simpler processes, much like how biology arises from the simple laws of QM. Is this correct? If so, then with that definition of consciousness, I agree with you. And we will learn more about it as time goes on.
Fourth: Yes, I agree. Chaitin's constant is my favorite exemplification of that idea.
Finally: "Do you think that this means your consciousness has nothing to do with your claim to be conscious?" Yes, that is exactly what I think. Although replace "consciousness" with "the act of experiencing existence" and that is a much closer semantic match to what I am attempting to convey.
> 1. My claim to be conscious does have to do with the fact of my consciousness. (Agree?)
No, for the simple reason that you can write a computer program that prints out "I am conscious." Its claim of consciousness is only due to a program that someone wrote.
> 2. My claim to be conscious is completely determined by physics, since I would also make it in p-zombie world. (Agree?)
Yes, I agree with that.
> 3. Therefore, the fact of my consciousness must fall out of physics.
Were 1 and 2 true statements, they would indeed imply 3. But since I don't agree with 1, 3 also doesn't seem to be true.