"I propose a fourth: AI is now as good as it's going to get, and that's neither as good nor as bad as its fans and haters think…"
I suppose I disagree with "as good as it's going to get" … but for the time being (this decade?) this might be correct.
"I propose a fourth: AI is now as good as it's going to get, and that's neither as good nor as bad as its fans and haters think…"
I suppose I disagree with "as good as it's going to get" … but for the time being (this decade?) this might be correct.
Hard to take the rest of it seriously with them taking a position like that. I can't think of a time that's been true for any technology in my career. Whether they were ones I found useful or not.
No? When new tech arrives there is always a bunch of low hanging fruit around so there is quick progress immediately afterwards, but then it flatlines relatively quickly and progress is as slow as usual again.
So its a safe bet that progress will slow down to the usual level sooner or later, and it seems to be around now for text models, as this flatlining happens faster the more you invest into it since you exhaust the low hanging fruit faster.
> AI is now as good as it's going to get
And that's just silly, from my point of view.
I see the same thing with text models, you can say they improve but not in a game changing way, and you have the same scenario as cars. It wouldn't be wrong for a person to say "cars are as good as they ever going to get" 50 years ago, in his lifetime he was right, nothing happened with cars that would force him to change his habits during his life.
But up to 50 years ago cars changed quite quickly, so you could say it is weird to say cars wouldn't start flying or such in 50 years, but here we are, nothing dramatically changed.
Who are these two voices? Well, we've got fragmede, who, looking through their HN profile, works at NVIDIA as a "senior AI infrastructure engineer", and we've got mh-, who, looking through their HN profile, works at Wunderkind, which is "pioneering a new category of AI agentic marketing".
So, the two people in here pushing messaging about how great and valuable AI is, and how it'll continue to get better, have their jobs/livelihood tied to AI and people continuing to pour money into AI.
It almost always turns out that way. The people protesting the loudest for some idea universally are somehow tied to profiting by convincing people of that idea. Not that that means they're wrong, of course. Just providing context.
My opinion was simply in reaction to an, IMO, nonsensical claim:
> AI is now as good as it's going to get
And it would have been the same no matter what* technology we're discussing.
* Ok, someone commented NFTs. But I never considered that a technology.
(Since it's in the thread now: my opinions are mine, not my employer's.)
quite a lot has changed with cars
doesn't really have anything to do with the future of AI, tho
Air travel (thanks to efficiencies) costs a fraction of what it used to, look up what % of people have traveled by air and compare that to previous decades.
Cars are safer than ever, per mile driven, for their occupants and substantially more comfortable. They're also more efficient, but we've consciously traded that for heavier cars for crash safety.
Lossless audio codecs are ubiquitous, and there are low-loss low-latency wireless audio codecs deployed to billions of devices.
Agree with the AI statement, though.
That saves a lot of money, and despite complaining people seem to accept the tradeoff of cheaper flights for an unpleasant experience. That comes from using basically the same technology as a half-century ago, with more customers.
Not to mention airframe improvements in both aerodynamics and materials.