For example, I spent a bunch of money to install solar panels, house insulation, and soon a heat pump. They each have, respectively, about 9 year, 30 year and probably 15 year payback time at today's energy prices, so depending on lifespan and future energy prices it's an open question if it would've been cheaper just to stay as I was.
But there's the comfort factor (heat pump should regularize house temps) and security factor (still warm & cosy during a power cut). I'll allow myself a little feel-good factor of carbon emission reduction too. Maybe these can also apply to the question of using a heat-pump in the dirt-as-thermal-storage scenario here.
I suppose overall I'm of the mind we should be collectively treating carbon emissions as the highest priority and using a heat pump here might aid that?