Once you're multiparty that goes away, any other party can definitely betray you and then it's game over, your own integrity doesn't matter.
Historically NOBUS was about having a particular technological lead, that's very fragile and didn't work out long term. If anybody has that lead today it's the Chinese, but realistically nobody has such a lead.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_global_telecommunications... "The hackers were also able to access wiretapping systems used to conduct court-authorized wiretapping."
I'm not advocating for it, I'm just saying the computer science of this matters, and a lot of people have objections to the concept of NOBUS that are more ideological than empirical.
The first is that "us" would be something like "governments in the US"; but then that's too big of an organization to sustain as free from compromise. There are tens of thousands of judges in the US, well over a million police and military. All it takes is one of them to be corrupt or incompetent or lazy and the bad guys get to use the skeleton keys to everything in the world, which can unlock secrets worth billions or get people killed. And that's assuming they only compromise the authorization system; if they actually gets the keys it's practically armageddon.
And the second is that it's not just one government. If the UK makes Apple and Google build a system to unlock anybody's secrets, is Australia not going to want access? Is China? Let's suppose we're not going to give access to Russia; can the fallible humans operating this system fend off every attack once the FSB has been ordered to secure access by any mean necessary?
It's a system that combines many points of compromise with an overwhelming incentive for everyone from state-level attackers to organized crime to break in and severe consequences when they do.
“ideological” and “moral”, as bases for objection, mean exactly the same thing, though people will often use “ideological” to mean “based in principles of right and wrong that I don’t agree with” and “moral” or “ethical” to mean “based in principles of right and wrong that I agree with”.
(I will grant number 101 is the hard one to defend.)
Have any such system been built?
https://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2015/12/22/on-junip...
But also, Dual EC was suspected of being backdoored from day one, was slower than existing CSPRNGs, and was therefore avoided like the plague. Whereas the premise is that if you put all the world's secrets behind one set of keys, there doesn't exist a level of defense that can withstand the level of attacks that will attract. Which doesn't apply when it isn't widely used.
On top of that, the attackers would be the likes of foreign intelligence agencies, and then them not getting it and the public not hearing about them getting it are two different things.
The backdoor is a vulnerability even if you don't have the keys because it requires the trappings of third party access. If you try to get something in the shape of a backdoor through code review, you should get knocked back. But if something in the shape of a backdoor is required then a change in who has the keys to the lock is much smaller, more subtle and easier to sneak in.
Also, "never getting caught" isn't what NOBUS means.
But the Juniper hackers are the NOBUS failure because changing the locks on a backdoor that somebody else had installed is easier than getting one installed yourself.
Except that it was intended to be "nobody but the us (i.e. the NSA)" and now you've got China using it.
NOBUS or not, if your adversary controls your source tree, you're boned. Here, the adversary replaced "our" NOBUS backdoor with theirs. Two different backdoors, different keys, same structure.
[1]: "The Full Story of the Stunning RSA Hack Can Finally Be Told," https://www.wired.com/story/the-full-story-of-the-stunning-r...