People can make utter trash on Bake Off, get honest critiques, and yet the vibe is _still_ good. It's really great.
Now a bit off-topic: Bake Off has completely put me off baking myself. Nearly everything always goes wrong. And as this article kind of says: these people aren't _really_ amateurs. So I'm watching and thinking "if these above-average bakers are having this much trouble, I'm not even going to try"