How many companies now run TLDs? Yeah, .com is centralized, but between ccTLDs, new TLDs, etc., tons. And domain registrars and web hosts which provide DNS services? Thousands. And importantly, hosting companies and DNS providers are trivially easy to change between.
The idea Apple or Google can unilaterally decide what the baseline requirements should be needs to be understood as an existential threat to the Internet.
And again, every single requirement CAs implement is irrelevant if someone can log into your web host. The entire thing is an emperor has no clothes thing.
I always love when people bring the ccTLDs into these discussions, as if Google could leave .COM when .COM's utterly unaccountable ownership manipulates the DNS to intercept Google Mail.
Why is this more likely to happen than a rogue CA issuing a false certificate?
Also, Google has chosen to trust .com instead of using one of their eleven TLDs that they own for their own exclusive use, or any of the additional 22 TLDs that they also operate.
That isn’t possible with .com
This is not the case with a CA, however; you are forced to trust all of them, and hope that when fradulent certificates are issued (as has happened several times, IIUC), that they will not affect you.
But also the issues of segmentation are pretty much a total shift of the goalposts from what we were discussing, which is what actually happens when malicious activity occurs. In DNS, your only option is to stop trusting that slice of the tree and for every site operator to lift and shift to another TLD, inclusive of teaching all their users to use the new site. In WebPKI, the CA gets delisted for new certificate issuance and site operators get new certificates before the current ones expire. One of those is insane, and the other has successfully happened several times in response to bad/rogue CAs.
(Repost: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38695674>)
If you want to see what happens otherwise, just look at the gTLD landscape. Still, genuine power abuse is relatively rare, because to a large extent they are selling trust. If you start randomly taking down domains, nobody will ever risk registering a domain with you again.
Having a healthy competitive market for DNS services is good enough.