Hacker News Reader

It's not a really a choice in the Culture. There is zero chance of the Minds abdicating and submitting to human-only rule.

I doubt it would be a choice with AGI, and certainly not with ASI. It might seem like a choice, because true ASI would be persuasive enough to make it appear that way.

View on HN

Discontent Culture factions do sometimes break away, though; if letting the minds do everything was unpopular, you'd expect the human population to drain away that way, but that mostly doesn't happen (main example would be the Gzilt, who never quite signed up in the first place).

Yes, however unrealistic it may be, several factions in the Culture universe do claim to be the masters of their Minds, or refuse to instantiate them.

> It's not a really a choice in the Culture. There is zero chance of the Minds abdicating and submitting to human-only rule.

Why should they? They're sentient beings living in The Culture too?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com