This is the classic tradeoff. (it's similar to the bias variance tradeoff, or fox and hedgehog analogy)
Monolithic systems are scalable and efficient when well-governed, but brittle under errors or bad leadership (e.g. China closing its ports in the 14th century had centuries-long repercussions).
Distributed systems are less efficient but more resilient to errors and poor governance.
It’s not always one or the other though. American founding fathers found a right set of tradeoffs in designing checks and balances (like separation of powers) and federalism structures that harden the system against bad governance (though this is under strain today).