You're raising a sensible point, and most of the objections raised here are invalid. But it nevertheless turns out (surprisingly, to me!) that your argument doesn't work. This topic came up a lot during the short-lived superluminal neutrino excitement last year, and one good discussion of it by Sean Carroll can be found at:
http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2011/09/24/...
That post includes a link to a paper by Bob Geroch that goes into the topic in detail. The very short summary is that there is no mathematical necessity for "causality" to be defined just by relativity: the union of the relativistic definition and some other well-defined causal theory can work just as well, even if that theory involved faster-than-light travel.
So thank you for raising a very good point about this topic, even if it wasn't quite accurate. And to those who've objected here: unless your objection explicitly quoted Geroch, odds are very good that they're wrong.