The real problem is where does the post-hoc nature of words interact with the world of actions? They're highly separable. In one hand we have conscious will created by words, on the other is the wordless world of memory integration, consolidation, cognitive mapping, planning. All thought is wordless, we know this as of 2016 in aphasia studies, the question is if the words are arbitrary, what we doing using them in place of thought? Are we dumb, insane, or just wiling to live in slumber using them to go nowhere? If you look around carefully, nowhere is where we're going, and fast.
Thoughts aren't about things, they are things.
“We refute (based on empirical evidence) claims that humans use linguistic representations to think.” Ev Fedorenko Language Lab MIT 2024
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7415918/
btw the levels of folk science inhabiting engineering is tsunami. the whole field needs to be taught how to deal with the contradictions in scientific practice and discourse to get out of the vortex you've built for our species.
Probably you're not really a linguist, you're in a sub-field like NLP, generative or construction, which is only linguistics coded for engineers.
This is amateur hour in HN.
- It's great that you mention Stitch, because what I'm trying to tell you is directly related to his theory as presented in e.g. Mindreading. What he terms "desire detection mechanisms" are what I'm referring to as our ability to discern intent, which is how you're able to make sense of other people's actions (whether verbal or non-verbal).
It's either a troll or someone with problems. Since the username is "mallowdram" (melodram(a)) I'm leaning towards prankster.