I don't know how companies can be convinced to do ad placements like these, or if they simply rely on getting enough conversions from accidental clicks from unknowing users to make out in the end.
Either way, it's a bad practice and something I'd equate with a torrent site or rapidshare.
In the end, the advertisers don't really care (at least if they understand the math, which many don't). They care only about their ROI. If they pay 20 cents a click and make 40 they're happy, if not they aren't. Sure you could perhaps get rid of all the shaky grandpas, pay 40 cents a click, and make 80, but it's the same ROI.
What you really end up with is a cottage industry of people making websites that can convert shaky grandpas better than real advertisers because just like spam, some non-zero percentage do convert. That's why you see some stupid ID fraud ad there. Shaky grandpas are terrified of the evil hacker who wants to steal their identity.
I think shaky grandpa should be the internet standard term for worthless clicks.
The contrast on the background is much lower than the federal 508 standard for contrast and I think has changed to over the years to a lighter shade as Google "optimizes" it.
One is an ad and one is a search result, is there much difference? Given the average quality of monitors, I think those are designed to fool even otherwise sharp eyes.
On a CRT this isn't a problem, but I imagine that many people have their LCDs at an angle which isn't perfect for viewing such contrast differences ... and if a user (like my parents) are not as accustomed to playing "spot (and ignore) the ad" based on content as we are, then they might completely miss the visual cues as well.
Getting people to click on the ad instead of the search result makes Google about $20 per click because of the keyword, so no wonder it's designed to be almost invisible.
If you click on an ad that isn't relevant to you, there are three major harms caused. One, your time is wasted closing it and going back. Two, the advertiser may have to pay extra for a useless click. Three, Google (for instance) has to consider the likelihood that this is a useless or fradulent click, and possibly reimburse the advertiser if so.[1]
All of these are bad for Google (for example). The offset gained by a few dollars in revenue is probably not going to counter that, because what they really want is users to continue using their search engine and they want advertisers to be happy with the clicks they pay for. Those are really important for them to keep. Tricking you into clicking useless links is bad, bad, bad. (Adwords hosted on someone's website is another story; that person might not feel the same way.)
But if, on the other hand, the ad actually is relevant to you, then it's great for all three parties if you click it. So I'd hesitate to attribute these UI choices to trying to fool people.
Disclaimer: I can't remember the last time I clicked on an ad anywhere on the internet, except by accident. But that doesn't happen to me on Google or other reputable advertising-based sites.
[1] see e.g. http://support.google.com/adwords/bin/answer.py?hl=en&an...