Also note that the iPhone4 is now offered for free with most upgrade plans. If you have a 3G still kicking around on a regular plan, the upgrade path to (at least) the 4 isn't painful.
"People" are irrational. If you offer something "for free" today, with a long, expensive contract, they will be all over it.
Off-contract: Customer: "I'm thinking of switching to provider B as my bills are high." Provider: "I'm sorry to hear that, can I knock $15 off your bill?"
On contract: Customer: "I'm thinking of switching to provider B as my bills are high." Provider: "Certainly, that'll be $200." (Or your remaining ETF amount.)
But hey... free phone!