In the modern world people can choose obvious evil choices because it makes them money, but because the damage is spread across the entire world and only slightly makes peoples lives worse it is ignored. Our laws are setup for a world like this. But there needs to be then same sort of legal incentives to keep people in line at this scale. Where if your choice results in one million human years wasted/made worse, society sure a shit is going to punish you hard because it benefits society to not waste one million human years.
Sure there is.
Denying categories of potentially life-saving treatments due to provincial laws causing hospitals to value legal considerations over medical decisions is one example.
Perhaps the phrase "statistical manslaughter" is a better description however.
If you engage in behavior with known and predictable risks, which then kills somebody, it is manslaughter. Like recklessly operating a vehicle or blindly throwing knives.
That sometimes your behavior doesn’t kill people is immaterial — manslaughter is being intentionally risky in your actions which leads to a death.
Or in the case of UnitedHealthcare, felony murder: their felony fraud in issuing false denials for their clients resulted in deaths — and deaths that result from a felony have a special charge.
> That sometimes your behavior doesn’t kill people is immaterial — manslaughter is being intentionally risky in your actions which leads to a death.
I was thinking more about laws enacted in the last couple of years in various US states which have guaranteed a rise in pregnancy-related deaths[0].
0 - https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/04/u-s-pregnancy...
Sadly, the insurers have a defense to this, and it has largely held up in court:
"We did not deny that person the healthcare that could save their life. We just declined to be the party to pay for it."
Plus I have no idea what the word "statistical" even means in this context...
Example. I live in a mountain town. Our ER takes hours. I can go to one of the multiple nearby doc in a boxes and get seen in 15 minutes. My town HAS the resources to see those people waiting in the ER. We just don't allocated the resources that way.
My town is a ski town. We have WAY more orthopedic surgeons than we need, but it's extra profitable for them here and living rich in a remote ski town is nice.
My tiny town has multiple beauty skincare facilities with licensed doctors on staff.
It's not a 'we don't have resources' it's a 'we don't prioritize these lives'.
Which is fine. But don't lie to us and say there aren't medical resources.
We had to invent new crimes “against humanity” to cover it.
> The drafters of [the Nuremberg Charter] were faced with the problem of how to charge the men at the Nuremberg Trial with committing the Holocaust and other state-sanctioned atrocities committed in Germany and German-allied states by the Nazi regime. As far as German law was concerned the men had committed no crime, but only followed orders. Not following orders however, in Nazi Germany, was a horribly punished crime. The problem in trying the individuals responsible for the German atrocities lay in the fact that, like in World War I, a traditional understanding of war crimes gave no provision for atrocities committed by a state on its own citizens or its allies. Therefore, to solve this problem and close the loophole, Article 6 of the Charter was drafted to include not only traditional war crimes and crimes against peace, but also crimes against humanity…
Also: stop comparing things to the Holocaust. Still more pretzel twists. All you have to do is not pursue this dumb rhetorical strategy of depicting policy you don't like as "murder".
As far as American law is concerned, causing the deaths of many people isn’t a crime because of uniquely awful regulatory regime dehumanizing those people.
> Also: stop comparing things to the Holocaust.
It illustrates well the point that “just because a killing is lawful doesn’t necessarily mean it shouldn’t be considered murder”.
I have cited how we did, indeed, have to do exactly that.
> comparing the administration of health care systems to the Holocaust
Yes. Both involve causing megadeaths in a way existing law is entirely unprepared for.
1) denial of care resulting in death has already has case law for murder, it’s typically geared towards people with a legal responsibility like a grossly negligent parent and does typically get treated as manslaughter but there have been extreme cases where murder was charged. This is where I think an attorney could sway a jury that insurers have a legal obligation to their insured. And particularly where the insurer is objecting to a medical practitioners recommendation/diagnosis/etc.
2) premeditation can be determined because the auto-deny decision has been made and programmed into their business systems.
There are jurisdictions where that’s basically all you need
And some of those decisions are, shall we say, justifiable homicide.
Intent and motive makes murder. “I will let these people die so I can be richer” is different than a bureaucrat who gets paid the same either way.
“We spend a lot” and “people make profit off denying and inflating cost of care which results in needless deaths” are not exclusive scenarios.
That's a strawman. No one asserted they all merged at the same time in a way that this sort of 30,000 foot overview would illustrate, nor that the effects would be instantaneous.
> I took the time to assemble and present the data
I mean, as a bit of feedback on that work, it'd be substantially more useful if the site said whether or not it's at least inflation adjusted. Population adjustment would be handy, too.