It might help a bit to understand that their origins where to exclude blacks, asians and jews from owning homes in a neighborhood [0].
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeowner_association#History
This is a knock on effect of the wetlands protection act (or maybe it's the clean water act, I forget which). Someone developing >1ac of houses (or duplexes or apartments or whatever) has to do stormwater management permitting BS. This probably means they leave one lot at the end and do like a stormwater catch pond in it or something (there's technical terms for this stuff I'm not using. The owner(s) is obligated per federal law to maintain whatever this solution is in perpetuity. This likely means some sort of HOA to handle that. And if you're gonna do that then why not have the HOA do more.
Communities should be empowered to self-regulate.
Any other way seems like absolute madness to me.
Depends on the HOA. My HOA board is an executive council. They don't have rulemaking authority.
And I think the evidence is generally that the prices are higher in well run HOAs.