I wasn't aware of that setting, so thanks for sharing. But as joshtynjala pointed out, I would like to still receive email notifications for repositories that I own. This global setting seems to prevent that, though I will try it to determine if that is definitely the case.
Unfortunately, that turns off emails for all repos that I'm watching, including my own personal repos. I still want emails for my projects, but a nice news feed of commits and things on the website for everything else.