> No, it should not. Try to explain why you believe that.
Uh, okay. Let's do a thought experiment: Suppose I take some violin lessons and acquire an as-yet-undemonstrated ability to play the instrument. Later, I perform at a violin recital; after this demonstration, my violin abilities have become demonstrated.
Then I have a kid: 1. Can that infant child play violin? No. Thus they have not inherited my ability to play violin.
2. Has that infant child ever had a violin recital which demonstrated their ability to play violin? No. Thus they DEFINITELY do not possess a demonstrated ability to play violin.
Again, this should be obvious. I feel like you must be misunderstanding what the words "ability" and "demonstrated" mean.
> If you try to learn guitar and fail, there's a good chance your kid will also fail if tries.
You are no longer talking about "demonstrated ability." You are describing a lack of aptitude for guitar, which (as I said in my last post) is a different thing. Besides, pretty much anyone with working hands can learn to play guitar. It's not really a question of aptitude, it's a question of investing time and money into learning. Most skills are like that.
> We most certainly are born with skills. Speed of learning is a skill.
Well, no. It's an aptitude.
aptitude /ăp′tĭ-too͞d″, -tyoo͞d″/
noun
An inherent ability, as for learning; a talent.
skill /skĭl/
noun
Proficiency, facility, or dexterity that is acquired or developed through training or experience.
> how did the first person obtain the skill
What "first person"? I'm not talking about cavemen, I'm talking about our society and the impact that the socioeconomic status of a person's family has on their career relative to the impact of their innate intelligence. If you want to tell me that those factors are closely linked, you're flatly wrong: Many rich people are stupid, and many poor people are intelligent.