Hacker News Reader

Comment by juiceandjuice | Hacker News Reader

This is such a stupid assumption. Apple's maps will never reach Google's.

Why? Because Google's business model is so heavily dependent on highly accurate maps at so many levels. There's been posts on HN regarding Google's usage of Streetview/OCR to improve their map directions, and it's absolutely critical that their maps be the absolute highest quality in terms of content and accuracy of that content for their driverless cars.

Google has and will continue to invest massively in maps, and no user feedback will ever approach that investment.

View on HN

Apple's maps will never reach Google's.

There is one way Apple's maps already surpass Google's: no advertising.

For instance the iOS 5 Youtube app never showed ads, whereas the new app store one shows tons of them. Sometimes 1/4th of the screen is advertisement.

I'm sure it will be the same way for maps. Looking up a bus route, looking for used cars for cheap? Oh you are walking someplace, wouldn't you like a bicycle? There's five StarBucks® on your route!

No thanks. If I need the better features in Google Maps then I'll use it, but I'll go with the ad-free version if it works well enough.

Apple's Youtube app also made a large portion of content unavailable because of lack of advertisement support.

The advertising isn't intrusive in the Android version of Maps.

It's also worth noting that, like search advertisements, Maps advertisements have the potential to be useful. If I'm looking for a restaurant near some location, restaurants that care enough to advertise in Maps for that location could easily be worth considering.

True, because Google is trying to use Google Maps as a hook into Google+ Local. For maps, it all comes back to local search.

> There is one way Apple's maps already surpass Google's: no advertising.

For now. Let's not forgot Apple tried to push full screen, "interactive" iAds. While banners ads have been more popular, the extra screen real estate on the iPhone 5 could eventually become devoted to ads.

I guess in that sense, my 'map app' (a photo of the street I live on) also surpasses google's because it doesn't have any ads.

No, maps are not of any use if you can't use them and rely on them. It has nothing to do with how Google chose to monetize it. If your ad-free version works well enough - great. But the whole point is that the new maps don't work well enough.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com