Not saying AI is similar in impact to the loom or something, it just occured to me how close this is to early Luddite texts.
Not saying AI is similar in impact to the loom or something, it just occured to me how close this is to early Luddite texts.
And unfortunately (for humanity) this has been the status quo for the whole civilization. Small ruling elite class (you might designate them as masters, lords or employers) with all the wealth, minimal or no "middle class" and lots of poor people (you might designate them as peasants or slaves or workers).
The only exception to this has been the period of time since World War 2 when in most of the "western" countries the middle class demanded and took their share of the wealth. That's the time when modern well-fare states were born, universal health care became a thing, working safety improved, education became accessible. etc.
All these were NOT given by the elite but TAKEN by the working class via social reforms, workers unions and social democracy.
The capital owning class wants to take all these away and they're succeeding.
So yes, in fact the Luddites were not against technology, they were against the unilateral and uneven distribution of wealth produced by the technology.
It was after the Black Death.
Similar circumstances, if you think about it.
Somewhat unprecedented in human history. All because intelligence had scarcity. AI changes that.
AI is the real dream of the capital classes. It makes intelligence cheap potentially undoing the very thing that gave birth to the last century's middle class. In the long term, given current trends, I wouldn't be surprised if these AI technologies revert us back to most of human history -> where the world is very unequal, meritocracy dies and most of us are trying to just exist/survive whilst the capital holders have abundance. It explains the large valuations as well of AI/Tech lately and the weird deals going on; this isn't a game of economics anymore; its an arms race of power in the new world structure. I suspect to these people no amount of money is enough; if you win you win for the next era of humanity.
Many Luddites were shot against the wall or jailed. History often lies because it is written by the winners.
The roots of global civilization are brown and frothy.
Explains a lot.
Explains it to my satisfaction!
It's telling that the nobles of agricultural societies generally still hunted, and often reserved that privilege.
It's not hard to see a future where the workers displaced by AI get pushed to the sidelines and fringes of the society while the capital holders hoard more wealth and get the benefits of the "value" created.
We already have half the population on this planet living in slums without access to economic means and in the "developed" countries larger and larger group of people are barely hanging on either already displaced and unemployed or working jobs below living wages.
Frankly, It'd stupid not to be concerned.
This is, of course, an attribute of capitalism.
Like carpenters, gardeners and farmers, there are very few software developers who truly have the luxury to treat their work as a craft and not a factory output.