Where? This is a thing which always pops up in these debates because it is a deep-rooted fear, but are there countries where this is a thing?
Where? This is a thing which always pops up in these debates because it is a deep-rooted fear, but are there countries where this is a thing?
> A part of eugenic politics would finally land us in an extensive use of the lethal chamber. A great many people would have to be put out of existence simply because it wastes other people's time to look after them.
Shaw and other Fabian Society members were supporters of the group now called Dignity in Dying [0], which used to be called The Voluntary Euthanasia Legalisation Society and was founded by a doctor.
Nazi Germany committed involuntary euthanasia of disabled people in a program called Aktion T4 [1]. It's probably not an accident that Dr Kevorkian, an American, started publishing his euthanasia papers in Germany. Before that he was trying to harvest blood and organs from inmates, which is another area where the incentives seem very bad.
I can't comment on how often modern assisted suicide programs recommend it to disabled people who don't want suicide. But it's clear that Kevorkian was not careful about who he recommended assisted suicide to. So given the strong desire of some people to euthanize the disabled against their will, the lack of carefulness is concerning and suggests that it likely happens with some regularity except in exceptionally run programs.
I don't think things are as bad, but I also think that old age in poverty is a valid reason for euthanasia if there is no alternative. If the society is cruel to the poor, holding poor elderly as hostage to improve situation is cruelty on top of the cruelty.
https://thewalrus.ca/assisted-dying/
https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/article/doesnt-line-up-mps-c...
Eg maybe a 16 year old who wants to end their otherwise healthy life might, 20 years later, be glad they didn't.
That seems less likely with someone who is almost certainly going to die (and probably painfully to boot) "soon".
Equally, they might spend decades of their life in misery wishing that they had been able to.
I think it's okay for us to try and avoid the irreversible mistake, but yes, it's very arguable that living years you didn't want to live is also an "irreversible mistake".
I watched a documentary where they interviewed a bunch of people who attempted suicide and talked to them about the entire experience and mental state. Out of the maybe ten that they interviewed, only one said that he wished it had worked. That doesn't mean it's only 10% though... they didn't get to interview the ones that succeeded.
Especially if the person has already admitted to trying to commit suicide (which they presumably did considering the context from parent comment).
I don't think that's the same as what you're describing.
What's downvote-worthy about this comment?
It's in response to mine, and even though I don't really agree with it, I don't see what's so objectionable that it needs some sort of admonition?
>Her last hope was a $4,000-a-month drug that her doctor prescribed for her, but the insurance company refused to pay.
>What the Oregon Health Plan did agree to cover, however, were drugs for a physician-assisted death. Those drugs would cost about $50.
Randy Stroup [2]:
> Lane Individual Practice Association (LIPA), which administers the Oregon Health Plan in Lane County, responded to Stroup's request with a letter saying the state would not cover Stroup's pricey treatment, but would pay for the cost of physician-assisted suicide.
Stephanie Packer [3] (although in this case she inquired herself):
> Then her doctors suggested that switching to another chemotherapy drug might buy her time. Her medical insurance company refused to pay. She says she asked if the company covered the cost of drugs to put her to death. She was told the answer is yes — with a co-payment of $1.20.
T. Brian Callister, MD, FACP, FHM [4]:
>When I spoke with the insurance medical directors of the patients' insurance companies by telephone on separate occasions, both of the insurance medical directors told me that they would approve coverage for either hospice care or assisted suicide but would not approve the life saving treatment option.
> Neither the patients nor I had requested approval for assisted suicide, yet it was readily offered.
[1] https://abcnews.go.com/Health/story?id=5517492&page=1
[2] https://www.foxnews.com/story/oregon-offers-terminal-patient...
[3] https://nypost.com/2016/10/24/terminally-ill-mom-denied-trea...
[4] https://www.cga.ct.gov/2018/phdata/tmy/2018HB-05417-R000320-...
However, the price difference is probably a strong incentive.
Just to be clear: the insurance companies are the problem here; and more broadly this whole for-profit model of healthcare.