You’re just adding excuse on excuse here which is totally fine. People love thinking that a million factors are holding them back when the only thing actually holding them back is themselves.
You made an impressive list of 2 people who simply couldn’t move!
Fine, whatever those people absolutely couldn’t move or do anything to drive less or not drive at all. You really think this applies to all the people who claim to wish they could drive less or not at all? And you really think moving is the only way to drive less? And that the decision to move is one that can’t be made throughout one’s lifetime?
Grad school ends. Kids grow up.
But I’m sure there’ll just be another excuse at that time.
And again, there is nothing wrong with that. It just shows that if a person continues to claim to value something and does nothing to live that value (besides make excuses and blame others), I do not believe that person actually values that thing.
> but if it means I'm spending 1 hour on daily commute instead of 4 in the metro area where I ended up living, you bet I'll do the stupid thing, as will everyone else
I did not!
Additionally you did not end up living anywhere. You chose to live there.
> people who are the victims of the decisions made by governments
If you see people as victims that’s how you perpetuate the problem. If a person says that they wish they could drive less or not at all tell them, “Change your life! Or admit that you don’t value that as much as you think!”
> Put simply, your solution doesn't scale
It obviously doesn’t have to scale. Anyone can make choices that they think will allow them to lead the life they value. If someone believes they value driving less or not at all, those choices are available to them!
They shouldn’t say, “Boy I’ll continue to dislike my life because the solution I see doesn’t scale.”
Additionally it obviously does scale because most people will do anything to avoid changing their life. The solution is right there for the people who actually want it.